How to Decide What to Play With Friends
You've all logged on, everyone's in the voice chat, and then comes the question nobody can answer: 'so what are we playing tonight?' Here's how to never waste another hour debating.
Why Groups Get Stuck
The paradox of choice is real. With hundreds of games across everyone's libraries, no one wants to suggest something and get shot down. So everyone says 'I'm fine with anything' while secretly hoping someone else will decide. The result: 45 minutes of scrolling through Steam.
Method 1: The Blind Vote
Everyone submits their top 3 games privately. Tally the votes. The game with the most picks wins. No debates, no social pressure. This is what Co-Op Now's voting system automates.
Method 2: The Elimination Round
Start with 6 candidates. Each person vetoes one game. Whatever survives is the winner. This works well for groups with strong dislikes — it removes dealbreakers without requiring everyone to agree on a favorite.
Let your group vote and find the answer in seconds.
Method 3: The Rotation
Each week, one person is the 'game master' who picks. No vetoes, no debates. This person rotates weekly. It means everyone plays something outside their comfort zone occasionally, and the group discovers games they wouldn't have tried otherwise.
The Meta-Rule: Decide Fast
The worst game night is the one where you spend an hour picking and only play for 45 minutes. Set a 5-minute timer for the decision. If no consensus, use the random method. Any game is better than no game.
Which co-op games can your squad actually play?
Compare owned games, squad size and platforms for the people you play with.
Co-Op Now's game picker combines library sync, voting, and randomization — turning a 45-minute debate into a 30-second decision.
Related Features
Browse Games
More Guides
Ready to find your next co-op game?
Sync Steam libraries, vote with your group, check PC compatibility, and track deals — all free.